I used about 5 pounds of ‘baking’ apples in this recipe – Jonathan apples. Weighed using the non-fancy-kitchen-appliance method of putting a bag on the bathroom scale!
Make sure you peel the apples and remove all of the skin. The peeling itself only took about 15 minutes; the chopping and coring is the longest step in this recipe. But well worth it!
Mix your apple slices with the sugar/spice mixture! Most recipes I looked at suggested cooking the apples on low for 10, 12, or 14 hours, stirring every once in awhile. This can vary widely depending on your slow cooker / crock pot – mine ended up looking done in only 4 hours! It may be because my crock pot is black, so food cooks faster than the white ceramic version. Even though the apples were incredibly soft in a short amount of time, I left this in the crock pot for 11 hours – on simmer and then the warm setting.
It’s important to get your apple butter as smooth as possible. This doesn’t take much after so many hours in a crock pot! Use an immersion blender or a regular blender. I used the ‘stir’ and ‘chop’ settings and only blended this for a minute or so.
I did not can this apple butter; instead I sterilized my half pint Kerr jars and stuck them in the fridge after filling. To sterilize your jars, wash them with soap and water {or run them through the dishwasher like I did}, while a large stockpot is heating up to a boil. To complete sterilization, boil every piece of the jar – lid and rim included for several minutes. I used metal tongs to carefully pull each boiling piece out of the pot to dry.
This recipe made six half-pint jars, which will keep for two weeks in the refrigerator, or will stay fresh in the freezer for a few months!
Follow Chicago Jogger: